Friday 30 April 2021

Tipping Point

The latest LiberFaciorum post from my friend Jasper, who as I mentioned a little while ago has advanced over the last year from lockdown-scepticism to full-scale covid-conspiracism, includes a Tweet from Dr Zoe Harcombe, alleging that nothing unusual is happening in India at the moment and that reports of covid deaths there are exaggerated by Western media. I don’t know what her expertise in this matter might be, as she is a dietician, and a much-criticised peddler of pseudoscience. But Jasper has reached the point where criticisms of someone’s integrity or expertise by the mainstream of their profession is precisely a reason to accept their opinions: my enemy’s enemy is my friend. Not that I expect he’s checked her out.

It's interesting (if depressing) to speculate how individuals make this progress. Once you adopt a very non-mainstream opinion, for which there is, ipso facto, little evidence, you must cast around to find that evidence and before long every little scrap of overinterpreted information has to be pressed into service. The world in general isn’t going to endorse your opinion and you have to come up with an explanation why. As far as covid-sceptics are concerned, the most egregious manifestation of this is their approach to medical professionals. There has to be something that explains why the overwhelming majority of doctors across the world, trained in a wide variety of independent institutions and operating in very different political and professional structures, are all saying the same thing: they must have been brainwashed, or bribed. Following Jasper’s promoted links I have found myself staring on my computer screen at the most extraordinary statements of rage and hate against doctors – as the chief promoters of lies, dangerous medicines, and fake diagnoses and death certificates, it must be infuriating for sceptics to see them taken so seriously by the rest of the population.

Just in case there was any doubt, I do talk to a great number of people from day to day and find little evidence of the situation Jasper believes is prevalent. Most of our congregation, being older folk, have been vaccinated and a great number double-vaccinated, along with people I meet in the Co-Op, the cafes, the school, the streets in general. Nobody has had a reaction worse than a few hours of headaches, while Jasper believes ‘if you don’t end up blind or dead from your vaccine you’ve been lucky’; technically this may be true, but not very lucky as it was never all that likely to happen. He reports that ‘I am overwhelmed with the amount of people I am discovering daily, cowering in their homes, nervous wrecks as a result of the fear inducement in order to get onboard a clinical trial [ie, receive a vaccine]’. I, on the other hand, haven’t heard of a single one. We live in very different worlds, he and I.

Unless you’re going to do a volte-face and admit you were wrong, when contrary evidence grows, the only option is to double down, and that forces you further and further away from the surface. Jasper now seems to be veering off into climate-change scepticism as well, because anything there is a consensus over becomes suspect. It’s a strange alternative world, but a very beguiling one as it provides its residents with a sense of self-worth: look at the photographs of the last anti-lockdown protest in London and you can see a woman with a placard reading ‘We R the ones you failed to fool’. Jasper has been known to make references to sheep and other allegedly unthinking herd animals when describing the rest of us.

Just like the farther reaches of the climate change movement, there are similarities between covid-scepticism and Christianity, or at least the brands of it that take you far away from the worldview of most other people. There, you are also given a sense that you have a privileged insight into the way things really are beneath the apparent reality the herd accepts, but at the same cost. If your insight relies on denying the evidence everyone else accepts, and positing a hidden enemy who directs the deception, you’re inevitably pulled by the same current, forced to interpret everything you see in the light of that denial and polarising the entire world into facts which endorse your view and those which don’t (in short, lies). What a bargain to make.

No comments:

Post a Comment