Saturday, 24 November 2012

A Culture of Suspicion!

As light relief to having a go at my own religion, here's a short jab at non-Christianity for a change.

I know a number of people who are vegans and pro-animal campaigners. A short while ago, one of them put up this photo on a well-known social-networking site:


This prompted a lot of discussion, arising out of the quotation in the picture. I can't find the thread now so I can't quote from it, but it was mainly along the lines of how wicked Christianity in particular and religion in general is for promoting exploitation of animals, and, in contrast, how atheism, being natural and rational, promotes instead respect and kindness towards them.

William Ralph Inge? I thought. I recognise that name. He was, it doesn't take long to confirm if you want to, the famous Gloomy Dean of St Paul's Cathedral in the 1910s, 20s and 30s; this quotation is from Outspoken Essays, published in 1922 and based on an earlier lecture.

As always, it only takes a moment to look this up but you have to have a mental culture of suspicion. I suppose it may be having a background in studying history that I automatically want to know the context of any statement or fact I'm presented with, what the qualifications are of the person who is quoted or who reports an event. This is another tiny instance of our willingness not to question or investigate things that conform to our preconceptions, made all the more glaring because of the sad assumption behind it that atheists can't be unkind to animals or Christians promote their welfare.

2 comments:

  1. Good post. A "mental culture of suspicion" can be very useful. Obviously, atheism has absolutely nothing to do with being natural, rational, or with kindness to animals. As we are often reminded, atheism is merely a lack of belief in God, and this lack can go along with any other mental attribute imaginable.

    I love the way that the chimp picture has been chosen to mirror those NSPCC appeals which are supposed to put us in mind of the aftermath of violence or some other form of abuse. In reality, this little chap is probably happily snoozing after a satisfying bout of feeding or masturbation.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Well, quite, I wasn't going to point that out. It's completely anthropomorphic.

    ReplyDelete