There has never been anything Anglo-Catholic about St Andrew's, but in architectural terms it's a grand and impressive space. Its stripped-down Gothic style, grey stone and oak fittings reminds me rather of St John's West Byfleet - and so it should, as both were designed by Caroë, Oxshott church in 1910-12. And that's about all there is to say. The new edition of Pevsner says that the roundel west window was installed in 1970, but it does look as though it was composed of older fragments: where did they come from? Note the sedilia used to store kneelers, two things we presume St Andrew's no longer has a use for.
Thursday, 29 June 2023
Tuesday, 27 June 2023
Trading In A Name
The story of how the trademark was registered is quite
strange. At first the US Patent & Trademark Office apparently turned the
application down, as the applicant’s mark ‘shows a false suggestion of a connection
with the famous actress, Louise Brooks’, but reversed its decision after the
applicant argued that Brooks had not left an estate to assert rights to her
name. It obviously wasn’t in the interests of the applicant to mention that, whatever
might be the situation with the actual words ‘Louise Brooks’, a company called Louise
Brooks Estate did exist at the time in Kansas, founded in 1998 and since 2014
overlapping with Louise Brooks Heirs, which is still going; both entities were
run by Brooks’s nephew Daniel, who is 76 and still lives in Wichita. Louise
Brooks Heirs has a supportive relationship with the LBS, but unfortunately it
never seems to have occurred to Daniel Brooks to do something as weird as copyrighting
his aunt’s name.
Craftslaw.com uses this case as a way of talking about how
trademarks work generally, especially in the online world. Most of the crafters
who might use Brooks’s image, and even her name, aren’t claiming that their
goods emanate from any kind of official source, only that a ‘Louise Brooks t-shirt’,
for instance, is a t-shirt with Brooks’s face on it. That’s not a trademark,
just a descriptor, and the law deems that ‘fair use’; but as Craftslaw points
out, most online platforms such as Etsy or eBay (not to mention Facebook,
Twitter, and Instagram) will just play safe and take down any contributor complained
against, leaving it to the parties concerned to sort it out through the law.
Who’s got the money for that?
The founder and organiser of the LBS is Thomas Gladysz.
A couple of years ago I bought his book Louise Brooks: The Persistent Star, a
compilation of many of his LBS blog posts. Like a lot of fans of a lot of celebrities,
shows, or activities, Mr Gladysz comes across as amiably obsessive and the book
is a work of delightfully loopy scholarship. I really don’t know how he manages
to find out the things he does. My favourite example was this post, concerning billboard adverts on various suburban streets
in Kansas City for the 1926 comedy A Social Celebrity, in which Louise Brooks
took a prestigious second billing to the then major star Adolphe Menjou. This
is, of course, nuts, and yet it does tell you interesting things about the way
movies were marketed in 1920s America. A lot of the blog is like that: it
explores times, places and manners through the medium of this one actor, and
she becomes a prism for an entire world. It’s niche, but it’s genuine and even useful
work.
This makes it all the more galling that the entity
attacking the LBS is embodied in a slick-looking but horrible website whose articles
are either weird, general stuff lifted from easily accessible online resources mentioning
Louise Brooks from time to time, or personal attacks on Thomas Gladysz; and a ‘shop’
consisting of t-shirts or ‘art prints’ emblazoned with public-domain pictures
of the actress run through a Photoshop filter. If you want to spend your money on that, think of it as charity. There is no sign that it will
contribute much to what we know about Brooks and her times – to put it as mildly
as I can. I'm not going to link to it.
I hope that, if the trademark holder had an intention to remove the LBS blog as well, he would have done so by now. It’s there that the most valuable aspect of the LBS survives, the astonishing corpus of work Mr Gladysz has amassed over the course of 28 years of study, and for that to disappear would be a tragedy indeed.
Sunday, 25 June 2023
Relic
Anyway. I could argue that the brambles, self-seeded sycamores, and green alkanet that periodically invade this small space are nothing to do with me, but I like to try to keep the vegetation under control. It was while doing this yesterday that I spotted a little disc of metal on the ground. Despite the blobs of corrosion, it was easily identifiable as a 1936 penny. A little dip in some vinegar cleared off all but the most fixed bits of decomposition.
How long had the coin been there? There were 154 million pennies struck in 1936, a total only exceeded in 1962, 1966 and 1967, so they were hardly uncommon. It might have been dropped even after decimalisation in 1971, but it's more likely that it was hidden since long before then, waiting for the sandy earth here to be disturbed and washed away and then for me to find.
Friday, 23 June 2023
Come Holy Ghost, Do
On the second day of the Triennial Clergy Conference this week, I went for what was a short walk down the hill and back again, and got dreadfully lost, eventually making my way back to the conference centre hot, exhausted and half an hour after the beginning of the afternoon’s first lecture, but I got a nice photograph of some cows from a footpath I shouldn’t even have been on.
There were a lot of words. Revd Isabelle Hamley gave us
a series of Bible studies examining examples of spiritual change (when the Bishop
asked us to share with our neighbour what one insight we might take away from
the conference, Fr Benjamin beside me claimed that it would be Revd Isabelle’s
revelation that her native French has no separate words for tortoise and turtle
– ‘I tell my husband, it’s just the same animal in a different place’); Bishop
Ruth Bushyager of Horsham encouraged us to subject everything we did to the
test of whether it took people forward in discipleship; Dr Sam Wells of
St-Martin-in-the-Fields urged us to start doing ‘interesting things’ (the
Church had abandoned all these to the Welfare State in 1948, he maintained)
beginning with more interaction with our communities; and Bishop Tim Wambunya,
who told us a tale of discrimination which has led to him going back into parish
ministry in Slough. There was other stuff, but they were the headliners.
Over the years I have become less prone to plunge into
a depressive spiral at the Triennial, questioning the worth of my ministry and even
of my own existence. Partly this is because I’ve learned to see my clergy
colleagues as just as frail and ridiculous as me, and their self-confidence,
where it exists, as a bit of a show. It’s just as well, because the Diocese of
Guildford’s descent into monocultural Evangelicalism has now reached the point
where it feels hard for any other kind of crop to flourish. Accounts from my
colleagues indicate without any shadow of a doubt that if Bishop Andrew can wrest
a church from any kind of high-side-of-centre orientation, he will, without any
regard to what it may have been in the past, or the health and viability of its
current congregation. To stand in the main hall at The Hayes as we did this
past week for Morning or Evening Prayer, and find oneself surrounded by people holding
their hands in the air ‘like they’re trying to grab God’s bollocks’, as my old
vicar Fr Barkley so picturesquely put it, does make one feel less than fully at
home. I tend to keep my mouth shut because I know hardly anyone will understand
anything I feel inclined to say.
I was glad I stayed for the final eucharist, though. The outgoing cathedral dean presided, a woman, I have been told by two people independently, ‘who doesn’t give a shit anymore’, not that that was particularly in evidence. The Bishop presided and, notwithstanding what he does, his words usually come across rather well. This time he decided to finish his sermon by reminding us of the truth of our ordination by singing the Veni Creator. For someone it was the most natural thing in the world to follow him intoning ‘Come Holy Ghost our souls inspire’ with ‘And lighten with celestial fire …’ – only sotto voce – and within a moment or two that whisper went round the whole hall so those of us who knew it were all joined in with that ancient hymn linking us, not just to Anglicanism past, but to the whole of the Western Church. A glorious moment, if a lonely one.
Wednesday, 21 June 2023
Stay-at-Home
When I saw Harvey at the Albert Hall back in 2011 she
was, mainly, performing Let England Shake interspersed with some songs from White
Chalk and a couple of old favourites. It was an intense, but static experience,
somehow eroding both the ethereal strangeness of White Chalk and the shimmering
beauty – which contrasts with the bloody subject-matter – of Let England Shake,
and making both more ordinary. Catching PJH at the Brixton Academy during the
Hope Six tour in 2016 was a different matter. The Hope Six Demolition Project
was an uneven work as a recording: it truly came alive in performance, with a bigger
band than Harvey had ever worked with, the volume turned up to drown out
whatever doubts there might have been about the music. The concerts were
deliberately theatrical, intricately planned, and grand: it was big music
making big statements about human society and global citizenship.
To judge by the first two pieces of music from the album that have been released, I think I Inside the Old Year Dying live will be more a 2011 experience than 2016, and this time I would be not sat relatively comfortably in the Albert Hall but standing for two hours in a hot and crowded Camden Roundhouse. So I will listen to the record, and enter into the strange world of the new album, which seems so much more suited to smallness and intimacy, at home, and summon the Maestra into my garden, perhaps, rather than glimpse her across a sea of heads.
Monday, 19 June 2023
We've Come A Long Way, Mr Mayor
This was a secular event and I wondered what to
expect. Arriving a couple of minutes late, I found a hall full of people either
clapping their hands or waving them in the air to ‘Dynamite’ by Korean boy-band
BTS which I can fairly say fell well outside the parameters of anything I might
have anticipated. The new Mayor’s keynotes for his year of office are ‘positivity’
and ‘inclusion’, and you can’t deny that his inaugural event expressed that, as
we progressed through two local amateur choirs doing turns (though it struck me
that ‘I Want to Dance With Somebody’ is actually quite a melancholy piece of
work), funny children’s portraits of the Mayor projected on the wall, and
culminating in Fatboy Slim. More clapping and handwaving: it curiously reminded
me of evangelical worship, which shows how close that is to the wider culture.
I will have to reflect on that.
The Mayor’s promises to serve his community, and ours
to help him do so, said everything that needed saying. Life’s not all ha-ha
hee-hee, though, I couldn’t help myself thinking as I was showered in all that
community loveliness, in which it seemed absolutely required that we have a
mild titter every minute we weren’t listening to someone sing, and without
tremendous self-restraint I can see myself delivering a very jaundiced homily
indeed when the Borough gathers at the church a couple of weeks from now!
Saturday, 17 June 2023
Stages of Faith
Giselle gave me a print-out of an article by one Richard
J Vincent (who I can’t find out very much about – his name is attached to this
piece of writing and others) outlining a model for spiritual development which was
probably news to his evangelical church audience in 2004 when he wrote it. His point,
and I’m not sure how far it is his originally or comes from elsewhere, is that
evangelical church communities tend to aim at getting their members to be
committed, active and engaged, living the life of Christian service, and stop
there, leaving them to run into the buffers when they undergo any kind of
challenge to their faith, a challenge which Mr Vincent suggests is not only
likely but actually a necessary step towards a further stage of development. That is a stage which leads inward, he says, detaching ourselves from the things we
once thought were spiritually valuable, and ending in a greater degree of union with
Christ.
I see the point of this, but I question any sense that it’s
a tidy process. Mr Vincent and his sources also stress it isn’t, and yet the
very fact of describing it in terms of ‘stages’ (even termed ‘early’ and ‘later’)
tends to make it look neater than in fact it is. I can’t recall any single ‘Wall’
experience (that’s what the paper calls it) where my spiritual assumptions all
had to be questioned and reformulated; rather it seems to be something that happens
all the time, though perhaps I have yet to run into a very solid Wall.
Meanwhile you continue to discover more and more about yourself, things that
need unpicking and occasionally repenting; and in fact the spiritual life isn’t
only about divesting yourself progressively of the bad habits of the past, but,
sadly, also about chipping away the new ones, and the new delusions and
illusions, that you develop as time goes on. The soul may grow closer to Christ
over the years, but most of us need to go through the business of renewal and
reformulation over and over again.
Then again, how much of this just comes from age? One would hope that a soul might progressively shed its illusions and attachments to nonsense as the business of merely putting one foot in front of another becomes more of a concern, and when I think of such advances as I may have made spiritually I find it hard to tell the difference between changes that show me growing closer to the Lord, and those that just result from getting older!
Thursday, 15 June 2023
Released Into the Wild
However I do wonder whether I'm simply delivering nice packets of frog-shaped protein to the fish. I think the froglets are by the time they develop a bit big for the fish to tackle but who knows. I was going to close the tanks down and transfer all the remaining tadpoles out today, because apparently not all of them will ever metamorphose, and will remain as tadpoles; but now I think I may just leave them a little while yet. There are far fewer of them now so the remaining ones shouldn't be too stressed.
Tuesday, 13 June 2023
'Season of the Witch', Cathi Unsworth (Nine Eight Books, 2023)
When it’s worth reading a book’s Acknowledgments
because of their wit and warmth, that volume deserves high praise. Such is Cathi
Unsworth’s Season of the Witch – very possibly the best book about the early
years of Goth yet produced.
Ms Unsworth starts with four late-1970s bands which
defined what turned into Goth – Joy Division, Magazine, the Banshees, and the Cure
– and includes virtually everyone else you might have heard of over the course
of the next near-400 pages, but Season of the Witch isn’t a catalogue of What Robert
Smith Did Next and Where Nick Cave Got His Ideas. Serious-minded students of
the post-punk will get the information they might want (and will also, on p.277,
find the best explanation of what ‘subcultural capital’ means in a single paragraph
where Paul Hodkinson once took a whole book), but the pieces are scattered and
woven into something grander. This book is a single, unfolding story (the author
uses that word repeatedly) of how a subculture emerged in response to the state
of a nation which seemed to be in decline and whose revival took a malign and
darkened form.
In 1979 young Cathi Unsworth was the eleven-year-old daughter of
middle-class liberal Christian parents in a Norfolk village, reading Dennis Wheatley
under the bedclothes with a torch. There are two ‘witches’ who frame her narrative: the Wicked one, Margaret Hilda Thatcher, who her parents raged
against as ‘a traitor to her class, her sex and her country’; and the Good, a stranger
figure she became aware of at the same time and who her adolescent mind wondered
might be riding out at night to save Britain from the Satanic influence of the
Iron Lady – a figure with electric raven hair, black lipstick, and torn
fishnets on her arms, who went by the name of Siouxsie Sioux. The proto-Goth pre-teen
emerged from beneath her blankets to find her way, eventually, to the handful
of East Anglian venues that might play the music that spoke to her, to London
to find kindred souls and finally, at 19, to write for Sounds and share what she
felt about those songs, albums, and bands.
But she is not the focus of her own narrative: she
observes from a distance the interactions of the artists who express the malaise
of Thatcher’s Britain in their work, their combinations, fallings-out and
dramas, heard far off in Norfolk like armies clashing by night. Eventually, as
she says, they all knew one another, these often fractured souls, a sort of
cosmic kaleidoscope shifting and moving the individuals around like shards of
sparkling glass to channel the stream of Goth in new directions. But whereas histories
of Goth tend to organise themselves around the bands, thriller-writer Ms
Unsworth turns these eleven years, bookended by Mrs Thatcher’s ascension and then
downfall, into something like a myth – a blackly comic one, shot through with true
tragedy. We range from Siouxsie running through a train in a blind rage to hunt
the band members who’d abandoned her mid-tour, to the blanching realisation
that Elizabeth Fraser of the Cocteau Twins was working through her abusive
relationship with bandmate Robin Guthrie in music everyone else thought was ‘the
voice of God’, mainly because they couldn’t understand the lyrics. Wire called Season
of the Witch Goth as ‘Dickensian epic’; I think of it as a classical historical
drama with added backcombing: ‘Eyeliner Claudius’, if you will.
Where Art of Darkness is a stiff-legged Frankensteinian stumble through the Goth past, Season of the Witch gambols like a lambkin across a meadow scattered with Spring flowers. That’s not the mood, of course, but you get my drift. It would be hard not to enjoy it even if you had little interest in the subject as the narrative continually pulls back and zooms in filmically, delineates the peculiar local horrors that inspired Gothic souls from Melbourne to Morecambe, and offers us historical scope not just in the political landscape of the time, but in the subcultural forebears Unsworth points to at the end of each chapter. These ‘gothfathers and gothmothers’ (as well as the pointers to books and films the Gothic-curious might like to consult) are not always the obvious ones: as well as Poe and the Brontes we are also given Maria Callas and, most wondrously, Fenella bloody Fielding. I am an almost-exact contemporary of Ms Unsworth and can testify, as she does, to the formative influence of what Mark Kermode called the greatest movie ever made, Dougal and the Blue Cat, and Fielding’s eerily prophetic, Thatcher-prefiguring performance as the Blue Voice who wants to eliminate all other colours: ‘Blue is beautiful, Blue is best. I’m Blue, I’m beautiful, I’m best!’
This marvellous volume is not a textbook – it is a soap-opera
of both a grand and an intricate kind. But it is also a triumphant justification
of a way of being. Ms Unsworth titles her first chapter ‘The Rebel Alliance’,
insisting that ‘Goth in the time of Thatcher was a form of resistance against
stupidity and ignorance’, elitist but also meritocratic: ‘Those who created the
best music of the 80s came from all backgrounds and many of them overcame all
manner of abuse, poverty and neglect’. Her final paragraph is like the raising
of a banner on a battlefield:
… So if anyone picks on you for being different in any way, please use this book to hit them about the head with the facts and rest assured, you are in good company. Goth has been ridiculed and derided for decades as being miserable, morose and moronic … [but] it stands for all the essential forces of creativity, friendship and vision, not to mention humour … Forty years on, it’s time for the curse to lifted and the words spoken in darkness to be heard in the light. I am a Goth.
So much for the second work on its subject published this year. What former Cure member Lol Tolhurst’s in September will bring, we wait to see.
Sunday, 11 June 2023
Goth Walk XXXVI
It would be churlish to point out the paucity of deep black among the Walkers yesterday, pictured as we paused for a group photo at the fountain opposite the Old Bailey. After all, temperatures were in the mid-80s, and as we followed our route we took advantage of as much shade as we could find at the stopping-places, winding from Lower Marsh at the back of Waterloo, over the river and then up through Covent Garden and Holborn before finishing at the north end of Blackfriars Bridge. Our subject was the Gordon Riots, the few days in June 1780 when the Government lost control of the capital, a series of (some argue) proto-revolutionary disturbances which began with religious prejudice and ended in an all-out if disorganised attack on the 18th-century legal system. London seemed unusually loud as well as hot, and at various points I found myself competing with trains, police sirens and rickshaw drivers belting out Queen at enormous volumes, and we battled with crowds on both north and south banks of the river. The capital strikes back.
Friday, 9 June 2023
Sandbanks in the Sun
Wednesday, 7 June 2023
Visitation From On High
Now the focus of the Visitation has changed. We were asked
to lay out copies of our Health & Safety Policy, Safeguarding Policy, gas
and electricity certificates, and insurance documents, and get out the service
registers (although as far as I know the last are not legally-required
documents at all and there used to be bitter and recalcitrant clergy who didn’t
keep them). The Archdeacon had a checklist on his laptop, to confirm that we at
least had something that looked like the kind of thing we should. Having passed
that hurdle, we moved on to discussing the Church Development Plan about which
the Archdeacon was very supportive and encouraging and made a couple of
suggestions about points the diocese might be able to help with. We finished
with a wander round the churchyard looking at the flowers.
OFSTED it’s not, and neither should it be. I’ve heard
stories from colleagues in other dioceses of Visitations which begin with the
legal checking-of-documents bit but then move on to a closed-door discussion
between the Archdeacon and PCC members from which the incumbent is excluded – people
being told ‘you are not allowed to attend’ – and the result of which the priest
is sometimes not even informed, apart from a vague ‘it went well’. It sounds
like the Church’s traditional love of secrecy and power-games under the guise
of accountability, and I’m relieved we haven’t gone down that route here.
(I found this image by Googling ARCHDEACON. It depicts Revd Colley, Archdeacon and former Rector of Stockton. With his biretta, stole and shoulder-cape, he is clearly a Sound gentleman. But why is he, with so very serious an expression so we must assume he isn't taking the mickey, carrying a trumpet? Should this be standard issue for all archdeacons?)
Monday, 5 June 2023
Words, Words
It wasn’t the fault of the planning team that the non-eucharistic first-Sunday-in-the-month service had a few issues this week. The order of service was passed to me for setting and printing, I noted the lack of the Lord’s Prayer and popped it in but forgot actually to tell Gisele the lay reader who led the service based on her original notes. Our new sound system still has an annoying buzz on the audio loop for those using hearing aids, so the affected parties tell me – but that’s well beyond my ability to sort out at the moment.
This is the second time the team have led the service, and I offer the following observation without speculation. I notice that while I tend to err on the side of reticence and brevity in liturgical matters, if I hand liturgy to laypeople to devise they seem to prefer lots of words, and making them as lyrical as possible. This isn’t invariably the case (we have some lay intercessors who also keep their words simple and straightforward) but it happens often enough to be remarkable. I’m also nervous about straying too far from Biblical texts, and the language yesterday landed quite a distance from them (‘Early in the morning, in the multicoloured company of your Church’ being the most obvious example): I wonder whether laypeople realise how much of the liturgy is composed of chopped-up bits of Scripture or at the very least imagery and language drawn from it, rather than something someone made up at some point. In hymns, of course, a greater latitude is customary: a theological student once asked Archbishop Ramsey whether there was a readily-available dictionary of heresies, to which he replied ‘Yes, it’s called Hymns Ancient and Modern’.
Saturday, 3 June 2023
Wild Encounters
Thursday, 1 June 2023
'The Rossettis' at The Tate
To London to visit the Tate's exhibition on the Rossettis with Dr RedMedea and Ms Mauritia. It seemed on the pricey side and when the first room was full of Christina Rossetti's poetry and one painting I thought we'd been diddled, but in fact as we followed the route it was clear there was enough to justify the cost - even if art is always a bit exhausting, and art in one style more tiring than that, and when finally an artist is producing multiple versions of the same picture weary is not the word. The furniture made for a nice palate-cleanser. We liked Gabriel Rossetti's prints and drawings more than his lush and famous paintings which are technically stunning and emotionally empty: 'It's all about the hair!' said Dr RedMedea. Discovering that Ken Russell had made a BBC film in 1967 about the Rossettis full of Gothic nonsense means I will have to try to find it.