Without getting into granular detail there are two major points that strike me. The first is the differences these books reveal, not only between Irish wells and those elsewhere, but even within the overall category of 'Irish Holy Wells'. These are three similar (though not contiguous) midland, inland Irish counties, and yet their wells differ both from each others' and those in other parts of Ireland. This is interesting because when I was first starting out in this field in the 1980s Irish wells were treated en bloc as an uncomplicated reflection of ancient Celtic spirituality, whereas we now know this is very far from the case and much of the practice surrounding them derives from Penal-period Roman Catholicism or even later. Co. Monaghan possesses far fewer of these sites for its area than the other two; Roscommon's seem to be, by-and-large, better-preserved. There are hardly any of the wildly garish modern well-structures that so startled me when I read Michael Houlihan's The Holy Wells of County Clare in 2015; the only one that really fits that bill is Fr Moore's Well at Tully, Kildare, named after a late-18th-to-early-19th century clerical miracle-worker, and now maintained by its own local society: the humble well itself is surrounded by whitewashed walls topped with blue coping-stones and with a brightly-coloured statue of the BVM beneath its own Gothic stone arch to the rear. A local family looks after Fr Moore's hat. What the three counties do share is the overwhelming preponderance of well-dedications to St Patrick and St Brigid, so much so that even Our Lady, who dominates in the rest of the British Isles, only has a walk-on part in Ireland. And what is similar between Ireland and the UK is the sheer level of destruction of wells. Ireland's Celtic past and Catholic present have not been as kind to the country's holy wells as we once liked to imagine, and page after page of the Kildare book headed with empty boxes where a photograph should be and the information 'No visible remains' is especially disheartening to see.
What is nice is my second observation, that all three works represent heritage initiatives sponsored by their respective local authorities: each is published by its County Council supported by a range of public bodies. It is admirable that holy wells should be believed worthy of publicly-backed efforts to record and publicise. If only English counties felt able to do the same!





