Friday, 20 November 2026

Three Irish Holy Well Books

In fact, two of these three tomes, all of which are new to me, exist as downloadable pdfs and only one is an actual print volume. That's Tamlyn McHugh's Roscommon's Holy Wells (2025); the others are Patrick Reid, The Holy Wells of County Monaghan (2024) and Antoine Giacometti & Gillian Boazman, Holy Wells of County Kildare (2023). All include gazzetteers of sites and are admirably referenced, but each takes a slightly different approach. The Roscommon book has a more narrative account of each site, while the other two tabulate the information for the wells in a format which differs slightly from place to place. All include attempts to break down the lists of wells according to various criteria such as folkloric motifs, cures, saints' dedications, proximity to other significant sites, and, in the case of the Roscommon book, the kind of topography where they are located. The Kildare book is the most historically-aware, including a general introduction which outlines the special features of the history of the holy well in the island of Ireland, drawing on older publications such as Michael Carroll's Irish Pilgrimage and Celeste Ray's The Origins of Ireland's Holy Wells.

Without getting into granular detail there are two major points that strike me. The first is the differences these books reveal, not only between Irish wells and those elsewhere, but even within the overall category of 'Irish Holy Wells'. These are three similar (though not contiguous) midland, inland Irish counties, and yet their wells differ both from each others' and those in other parts of Ireland. This is interesting because when I was first starting out in this field in the 1980s Irish wells were treated en bloc as an uncomplicated reflection of ancient Celtic spirituality, whereas we now know this is very far from the case and much of the practice surrounding them derives from Penal-period Roman Catholicism or even later. Co. Monaghan possesses far fewer of these sites for its area than the other two; Roscommon's seem to be, by-and-large, better-preserved. There are hardly any of the wildly garish modern well-structures that so startled me when I read Michael Houlihan's The Holy Wells of County Clare in 2015; the only one that really fits that bill is Fr Moore's Well at Tully, Kildare, named after a late-18th-to-early-19th century clerical miracle-worker, and now maintained by its own local society: the humble well itself is surrounded by whitewashed walls topped with blue coping-stones and with a brightly-coloured statue of the BVM beneath its own Gothic stone arch to the rear. A local family looks after Fr Moore's hat. What the three counties do share is the overwhelming preponderance of well-dedications to St Patrick and St Brigid, so much so that even Our Lady, who dominates in the rest of the British Isles, only has a walk-on part in Ireland. And what is similar between Ireland and the UK is the sheer level of destruction of wells. Ireland's Celtic past and Catholic present have not been as kind to the country's holy wells as we once liked to imagine, and page after page of the Kildare book headed with empty boxes where a photograph should be and the information 'No visible remains' is especially disheartening to see.

What is nice is my second observation, that all three works represent heritage initiatives sponsored by their respective local authorities: each is published by its County Council supported by a range of public bodies. It is admirable that holy wells should be believed worthy of publicly-backed efforts to record and publicise. If only English counties felt able to do the same!

Wednesday, 18 November 2026

The End Is Nigh

The older I get, the more vertiginous I find myself. It now takes barely a trip up a ladder to hang Passiontide Veils over a painting to make me feel very unsteady, and a couple of holidays ago I decided I didn't really need to go up the last bit of a castle staircase to look out from the roof. I don't think I am any less surefooted than I used to be (yet), and I wonder whether it comes from a heightened awareness of how perilous the world generally is that seeps from one aspect of it to another. 

Since early October the church has been swathed in scaffolding and hoarding. In fact, the first task of my holiday was to call by on my way to Staffordshire and negotiate the inevitable fireworks as the contractors brought their laden vehicles in and out of the car park rented and jealously guarded by our neighbours the Day Centre. It all looks very dramatic but in fact the works concerned are quite minor, just the repainting and occasionally repair of the external timberwork and the odd tweak to a gutter. But because much of it is at high level, it requires all that scaffolding. The repairs had been reported in our Quinquennial Inspection for several quinquennia, so they needed to be done.

The contractors say the works are mostly complete, so yesterday I and Colin the churchwarden ascended the ladders along with Simon from the roofers and church photographer Miles to do a check. I could have left it to Colin, but the prospect of looking at the church, and the centre of Swanvale Halt, from an entirely different angle and presumably a position of safety would have been silly to turn down. I think I acquitted myself reasonably, especially as one ladder wiggled a bit at the bottom and only settled under my weight as I got to a certain height, but I managed only the first two levels and not the third. As for the rooftop ladder that leads to the belltower, you can still forget about that.

Friday, 6 November 2026

"Lighting the Candles"

Should you click on this picture you will, I hope, be taken to the result of eight years of investigating the history of the Catholic Movement in the diocese of Guildford. Just a warning that it's 280 pages long! It's taken all that space to do justice, if justice has indeed been done, to the churches visited, the vestries poked through, the service registers scanned, the parish histories pored over, and the people conversed with. It's a tribute not only to the faithful departed who have served all those communities of believers but all the living souls who have helped in any way. How the time will stretch now! 

Wednesday, 4 November 2026

A Room in Stanwell

Almost inevitably when the Diocese puts on some training that I think it might actually be worthwhile to do it turns out to be on a Thursday when I am usually off: today's session at a small community centre in Stanwell about suicide prevention was organised not by them but by the County Council. The first challenge was finding the stairs and I was not the only person who ended up circling the ground floor before being directed towards an unmarked door that didn't open but slid to one side. That initiative test over the whole session turned out rather good, very coherently and clearly focused on how to respond to someone who has suicidal thoughts. The training came from the communities bit of the Council and was accordingly multiethnic and multifaith, but it was no surprise that the majority of us were white (welcome to Surrey) and connected to churches rather than any other setting.

The main points are to raise the subject very baldly and explicitly if you have any worries that the person you are talking to may be suicidally-inclined. They might say it themselves, but are more likely to talk around it, hinting that there is something very wrong and hoping - maybe against their conscious intention - that you will ask. The next task is to work out how immediate their plans are: lots of people battle with self-destructive thoughts and urges but never get further than that and never plan to. And then there are the agencies to connect them with, if you can: you should always presume that raising the matter, however covertly, is an invitation to intervene, even if the individual claims not to want it.

These are good guidelines for encounters that might take place in a professional or general social context, say, someone you may meet at work or another setting. Many years ago, though, I got to know someone who was a high suicide risk and, more by blundering luck than judgement, kept them alive. They were already under the care of the statutory agencies and I can only hope that those are more active now than they were then. I'm not sure a phone call to a crisis centre would have made that much difference - though with more knowledge I might at least have been emboldened to try.

Photo: view from the window. There were no distractions. 

Monday, 2 November 2026

That Money Was Just Resting In My Account

A few years ago I wrote about David Tennant's (or more accurately writer Steven Moffat's) TV portrayal of a priest at the centre of a safeguarding storm and how far it seemed from any remotely credible depiction of how someone in that position would react. Now I find myself able to add to the sequence of bizarre media depictions of clergy in crisis, as The Archers' Alan Franks seems to have managed to avoid all the safeguarding courses the rest of us have to go on in just the same way as Inside Man's Fr Harry Watling had. The incumbent of Ambridge is a man of long and challenging experience, and yet when he gave dying parishioner Carol Tregorran his own bank details so she could make a donation to St Stephen's Church for flowers, anyone but him could see where the storyline was going a mile off. Now he finds himself the next best thing to suspended, unable to handle the parish's money and chaperoned in every pastoral encounter by a churchwarden, after Carol, unbeknownst to him, transferred several thousand pounds his way the day before she died, and her daughter made a formal complaint after discovering what had happened. 

The Archdeacon turned up on Revd Franks's doorstep and in their awkward encounter played the straightest of bats, correctly insisting there was a process that now had to be followed. It was the supposedly experienced priest's reaction that made me boggle. 'But I'm innocent!' the scriptwriters have him cry, apparently never having given a moment's thought in all his ministry to how these things pan out. Even if I hadn't been included in several cases which have involved the Diocesan Safeguarding Department, I would have known what happens through training and Church news outlets. For heaven's sake, a quarter of the bench of bishops are signed off duty at the moment for irregularities of varying sorts, you can't avoid that. 'Ray, how long have we known each other?' Alan pleads with the Archdeacon, as though that could or should make any difference, as though 'Ray-how-long-have-we-known-each-other' doesn't reflect exactly the attitude which has got the Church of England and other once-trusted organisations into the pickle they find themselves now. Where has he been? How come all these media clergy never seem to have done the training I've had to do? Repeatedly? Or be subject to the Clergy Discipline Measure?

He has a bit of a habit of this, does Alan Franks. Not so long ago he seemed utterly bewildered by how to handle a contentious baptism request when the answer was obvious, and last year reacted so unclerically to a pair of local teenagers who were terribly apologetic for accidentally breaking a vicarage window with an errant cricket ball that listeners asked questions about his mental health. Now, as is his wont, he has decided that his accuser 'feels I have wronged her ... I have to try to treat her with grace', while it's Mrs Vicarage Usha's turn to be furious and make churchwarden Neil Carter thoroughly uncomfortable with what in court would be unconscionable attempts to influence someone who needs to maintain strict procedure - and Usha, remember, is a lawyer, who of all people should be aware of how the system has to work. All it needs now is for Alan's daughter Amy who we haven't heard from in about 15 years to take out a contract on his accuser's life. Or maybe the Archdeacon's.  

Saturday, 31 October 2026

Poppy Incursion

Coming into the church this morning, my eye was struck by a bush in the garden which seemed to have flowered since I last looked at it. Closer examination revealed that these blooms were red wool made to look like poppies, hung on the bush from ribbons. Some were accompanied by laminated notes asking whoever might come across them to 'respect these signs of remembrance for the fallen in war', leaving them where they are.

My first response, to be honest, was annoyance. Nobody had asked us whether they could put them there. We manage the churchyard as a garden open to the public, but it's not a public space. And even if it was a public space, there's something objectionable about someone coming in and claiming a space they only own collectively with others for something they may think is important, which is just one of the reasons one might not like national flags being strung up from lampposts. Who do you think you are? Somehow the little notices feel more hectoring than had the poppies been left there with no explanation at all.

The person responsible may not feel that, though, I reflected. They may not be very conscious of how the garden is organised. They may not be intending to challenge anyone but just, indeed, remember the dead: crochet would be a pretty odd medium for a misguided 'patriot' to adopt. I wonder whether we will ever find out who they are. The weather is set to be relatively fair for a while, so the poppies are probably not going to end up offensively bedraggled: I will leave them there until Armistice Day and see whether anyone claims them thereafter. 

Thursday, 29 October 2026

Swanvale Halt Film Club: Godland (2022)

To say that any movie with very little dialogue but lots of landscape always meets with critical acclaim may be a bit cynical but it does seem to be a general rule. I am not sure there is all that much skill involved in taking static shots of mountains, and I found the facility on the VLC video player to skip forward ten seconds very helpful, but the performances in Godland are impressive, especially as the actors have so little to work with. 

It may be true that we have little real idea why people behave the way they do, as we tend to know only small slices of their lives and experiences, but a movie that leaves us to make up almost everything about what might conceivably motivate the characters we watch is of limited help in developing our sympathy for others. The reviews of Godland show how people even seem to see something different from me. Anna the elder daughter of the leading citizen of the tiny Danish settlement on Iceland which is the destination and charge of young Lutheran priest Lucas 'seduces' the clergyman, says one: as the 'seduction' consists of him leading her into his darkened house and then her head and shoulders seen in red light, that doesn't seem like an accurate description of the event.

Why is Lucas such a disastrous priest? As his host Carl points out, he chooses to take the most difficult possible route to the village rather than just sail there, supposedly to get to know the country and 'meet people', which he doesn't. The experience of conflict, causing someone's death, and sickness on the journey, clearly break him before his ministry even starts, but he appears to have no spiritual resources to bring to bear on the experience. His prayers are muttered in private and we never see him successfully carry out a single religious act, even before he begins. Reviewers clearly want to read him as a naive, pious priest 'eager to save souls' (as one says) who comes up against reality in a far-flung landscape 'like so many colonial clergy'. But we never see any evidence of his evangelistic eagerness, and every time anyone actually seeks his spiritual advice, including the man who becomes his enemy, Icelander guide Ragnar, he brushes them away. When did this begin? We never gain any insight, just have it presented to us.

Late 19th-century Iceland may have been, in a broad sense, a Danish colony (though it had been granted significant self-government in 1874), but it was hardly any more a pagan territory than, say, Middlesbrough at the same time. The island had been technically Christian since 1000 and by the high Middle Ages was as thoroughly Christianised as anywhere else. Its patron saint, Thorlak, was a 12th-century bishop now retrospectively thought of as the patron also of people with autism. Until Lucas proves himself completely incapable of doing what he's there for, it's not as though the villagers don't want the ministrations of a priest. They co-operate in building the church, two want to get married there and when Lucas refuses because it's not ready and they have an informal sort-of handfasting the villagers still include him in the party, and they all turn up to worship on the first day.  No, this is someone who was broken before he started, but we never have a hint why in a film that exchanges spectacle for understanding.